So I was rolling around the RPG Bloggers network, and came across a post on The Labyrinth regarding asinine statements about 4e. I agreed with him that the statement was asinine, but for very different reasons than originally stated, and we discussed it for a bit.
So Labyrinthian, who runs the blog, decided to put forth his points, and air all his dirty laundry about the system, to get my responses on it.
Many of the points, I had heard before. I tried to answer all of them as best I could.
But, as I am wont to do, my comment in reply to him ended up something like 8 pages long.
As such, I’m posting it here, and leaving Labyrinthian a link to it. It… it’ll just work better this way, I think.
Go read his post first (as I don’t feel comfortable copying his questions here without permission). Then read my responses below.